15 November 2026

Factors that affect the reliability of audit evidence

Under ISA 500, reliability depends on the evidence’s source, nature and the circumstances in which it is obtained. mia.org.my

  • Source: Evidence from an independent external party is generally more reliable than evidence produced internally.
  • Internal controls: Internally generated records are more reliable when the controls over their preparation and maintenance are effective.
  • How the auditor obtains it: Evidence obtained directly by the auditor—such as observing a control—is generally more reliable than evidence obtained indirectly through enquiry.
  • Form of evidence: Original documents are generally more reliable than copies or electronic versions, unless the controls over creating and maintaining those versions are reliable.
  • Authenticity and competence: The auditor considers whether the evidence is genuine and whether its source is knowledgeable and impartial.
  • Consistency: Evidence that agrees with information from other independent sources is generally more convincing. Conflicting evidence needs investigation.
  • Timing and relevance: Evidence should relate to the period and assertion being audited.

Note: An external document is not automatically reliable, and inquiry alone usually does not provide sufficient evidence. Auditors consider the quality of evidence, not just how much they collect.

Tiada ulasan:

Catat Ulasan