Prof Madya Dr. Mohamad Azmi Nias Ahmad
Pages
- Home
- Courses
- Doa
- Timetable
- My Publication
- Expertise
- Anugerah
- Jury & Examiner
- Conferences
- Publication
- Supervision
- Services & Administration
- Community Services
- Kursus dihadiri
- Milestone
- My Readings
- Quote of the day
- Archery
- Media Coverage
- Diary
- Kenangan & Yearbooks
- Movies
- Photo Folio
- Research
- Theories
- Mind Map
- Netiquette
- AI Tools
- Sejarah Dividen dan bonus ASB
- My Video
- My MBR
- Adiwangsa
- Grammar
- Panduan
- Sharing
- Memanah Duniaku
- Books (Bacaanku)
- My Diary
- My Checklist
- Testimony
- ISBN Application
18 November 2026
Closing Remarks for the Semester
Dear students,
As we come to the end of this semester, I would like to take this opportunity to thank each of you for your participation, commitment and effort throughout our Accounting and Finance course.
For many of you, balancing DBA studies with work, family and other responsibilities is not easy. Attending eTutorials, participating in the forum, completing assignments and finding time to study require discipline and determination. I appreciate the effort you have made throughout this learning journey.
At the beginning of the semester, we discussed our expectations, the ground rules for our eTutorials and forum participation, and how we would learn together. We also touched on the use of artificial intelligence as a learning tool. I hope these early discussions helped you approach the course with an open mind and a willingness to ask questions, share your experiences and learn from one another.
Throughout the semester, we have covered a wide range of accounting and finance topics. I would like to take a few moments to reflect on how these topics fit together and why they matter to you as professionals and future DBA graduates.
We began with financial reporting and accounting regulation. We discussed why organisations prepare financial statements and why these statements need to follow recognised accounting principles and standards. Financial reports provide information to people who depend on it to make decisions, including investors, lenders, employees, regulators and other stakeholders.
We also considered the different needs of internal and external users. Managers may need detailed information to plan and control operations, while external users rely on published information to assess an organisation’s performance and financial position. As professionals, it is useful to ask not only what the figures show, but also who needs the information and how they intend to use it.
We then explored measurement concepts and the accounting equation. The relationship between assets, liabilities and equity provides a foundation for understanding an organisation’s financial position. Every business decision has financial implications, whether it involves buying an asset, obtaining financing, earning revenue or incurring an expense. Understanding these relationships helps us see how individual decisions affect the organisation as a whole.
Another important topic was accrual accounting. We learnt that revenue and expenses are recognised when they are earned or incurred, which may be at a different time from when cash is received or paid. This helps us understand why reported profit and cash flow can tell different stories. An organisation may appear profitable but still face difficulties paying its suppliers, employees or lenders. For that reason, good decision-making requires attention to both performance and cash availability.
We also discussed non-current assets and depreciation. Assets such as buildings, equipment and vehicles support an organisation over several years, but they also involve costs, maintenance needs and eventual replacement. Depreciation helps allocate the cost of an asset over its useful life. More broadly, this topic reminds us that investment decisions should consider the long-term use and value of resources, not only the initial purchase price.
Through financial statement analysis, we examined how to interpret financial information rather than simply read the numbers. Ratios and other analytical tools can help us assess profitability, liquidity, efficiency and financial stability. However, a ratio becomes more useful when we compare it with previous years, industry information and the organisation’s circumstances. One figure alone rarely tells the whole story.
We developed this further through advanced financial statement analysis and the comparison of company performance. We considered how changes over time, relationships between figures and differences between organisations can help us identify trends, strengths and areas of concern. As managers and professionals, you can use these skills to ask better questions before making recommendations or decisions.
We also learnt about consolidated financial statements, which present the financial position and performance of a group of companies as a single economic entity. For those working with organisations that have subsidiaries or related businesses, this understanding can help you appreciate why looking at one company in isolation may not provide a complete picture of the group.
Our discussion of operating segments and foreign operations showed that organisations often operate across different activities, markets and countries. Performance may vary between business segments, and international operations may introduce additional considerations, including foreign currency movements. Understanding these differences can help decision-makers identify where value is being created and where greater attention may be needed.
We also considered broader issues in financial reporting. Financial information involves estimates, judgements and choices, and users should therefore read reports critically. This is where professional integrity matters. Information should be prepared and communicated fairly so that stakeholders can make decisions based on a reliable understanding of the organisation.
In financial planning and forecasting, we looked beyond past results and considered the future. Forecasts help organisations anticipate revenue, expenses, cash needs and possible risks. While no forecast can predict the future perfectly, preparing one encourages managers to examine assumptions, consider different scenarios and respond more confidently when circumstances change.
We also discussed corporate valuation, value-based management and corporate governance. These topics encourage us to think about how organisations create value over time, how decisions affect that value and how leaders can be held accountable. Good governance supports responsible decision-making, transparency and trust. It also reminds us to consider the interests of stakeholders and the long-term consequences of our actions.
Our discussion of agency theory added another perspective. Owners may depend on managers to act on their behalf, yet their interests and access to information may not always be the same. This can create conflicts that need to be addressed through effective oversight, appropriate incentives and clear accountability. Whether you work in a private company, public institution or non-profit organisation, these ideas can help you reflect on how decisions are made and whose interests they serve.
Taken together, these topics show us that accounting and finance are connected to many aspects of professional life. They help us understand how an organisation uses its resources, meets its obligations, evaluates performance and plans for the future. They also help us communicate more confidently with colleagues, management and other stakeholders.
As DBA students, you bring something valuable to this learning process: your professional experience. I encourage you to continue connecting that experience with the concepts we have discussed. When you encounter a problem in your workplace, consider what financial and non-financial information you need, what questions you should ask, and what evidence would support a sound decision.
The same approach will be valuable in your DBA journey. Your research can begin with a real problem, but it should also draw on relevant theory and reliable evidence. By bringing professional experience and academic research together, you can develop insights that contribute to both knowledge and practice.
I would also like to thank you for your contributions during our eTutorials and forum discussions. Your questions, examples and perspectives have helped make the course more meaningful. Learning from the experiences of others is one of the great strengths of a DBA class.
At the same time, I would like to apologise for any disruptions, changes to the schedule or difficulties we experienced during the semester. Thank you for your patience, understanding and cooperation throughout.
As we close this course, I hope you will take away more than knowledge for your assignments. I hope you feel more confident in interpreting financial information, asking critical questions and applying accounting and finance concepts in your current roles and future responsibilities.
Please continue to be curious, reflective and open to learning. As future DBA graduates, you have the opportunity to use your knowledge and experience to improve your organisations, support others and contribute positively to society.
Thank you once again for being part of this learning journey. It has been a pleasure to learn and share this semester with all of you.
I wish you all the best in completing your assignments, continuing your DBA studies and progressing in your professional careers.
Take care, and I hope our paths will cross again. Thank you.
20 bahan aktiviti berdasarkan Modul 6: Liabiliti Korporat di bawah Seksyen 17A Akta SPRM 2009
A. Soalan berpandukan pengalaman
Pernahkah anda melihat seseorang menerima hadiah atau layanan istimewa untuk mempengaruhi sesuatu keputusan? Pada pandangan anda, bilakah hadiah itu boleh dianggap sebagai rasuah?
Jika rakan sekerja meminta anda meluluskan tuntutan yang meragukan, apakah tindakan yang akan anda ambil? Mengapa?
Pernahkah anda berasa sukar untuk menolak permintaan seseorang yang mempunyai kedudukan lebih tinggi? Bagaimanakah keadaan itu boleh dikendalikan dengan berintegriti?
Jika anda mengetahui seorang pekerja menawarkan wang untuk mendapatkan kontrak, kepada siapa anda akan melaporkannya? Apakah yang mungkin menghalang anda daripada membuat laporan?
Pernahkah anda melihat prosedur organisasi tidak dipatuhi kerana mahu menyiapkan sesuatu urusan dengan cepat? Apakah risiko tindakan itu?
Jika organisasi anda belum mempunyai polisi antirasuah yang jelas, apakah tiga langkah pertama yang patut diambil oleh pihak pengurusan?
Bagaimanakah anda akan bertindak jika diminta menyembunyikan maklumat tentang bayaran yang mencurigakan daripada pihak audit?
B. Aktiviti perkongsian pengalaman
Kongsikan pengalaman apabila anda atau seseorang yang anda kenali perlu membuat keputusan antara kepentingan diri dengan tindakan yang betul.
Ceritakan pengalaman menerima hadiah, saguhati atau layanan daripada seseorang. Bagaimanakah anda menentukan sama ada ia sesuai diterima?
Kongsikan pengalaman melihat seseorang berani menegur atau melaporkan salah laku. Apakah kesan tindakan tersebut?
Ceritakan pengalaman apabila peraturan atau prosedur membantu mengelakkan kesilapan atau salah guna kuasa.
Kongsikan pengalaman bekerja dalam kumpulan yang mempunyai pembahagian tugas dan tanggungjawab yang jelas. Bagaimanakah kejelasan itu membantu mengurangkan salah faham?
Pernahkah anda menghadiri ceramah atau latihan integriti? Apakah satu perkara yang paling anda ingat dan bagaimana anda boleh mengamalkannya?
Kongsikan pengalaman apabila pihak atasan menunjukkan contoh yang baik dari segi amanah dan integriti. Apakah pengaruhnya terhadap orang lain?
C. Daripada kisah benar
15. Cek bernilai RM25,000
Pada tahun 2006, seorang bekas pegawai kanan Alcatel Network Systems memberikan cek syarikat bernilai RM25,000 kepada seorang pegawai perolehan Telekom Malaysia. Tujuannya adalah untuk mendapatkan maklumat tender berkaitan sistem komunikasi mudah alih. Kes itu kemudian dibawa ke mahkamah. Tertuduh dijatuhkan hukuman penjara enam bulan dan denda RM125,000.
Renungan: Apakah kesan perbuatan seorang pekerja terhadap nama dan tanggungjawab organisasinya?
16. Subkontrak penyewaan kapal
Pada tahun 2021, Pristine Offshore menjadi syarikat pertama di Malaysia yang didakwa di bawah Seksyen 17A Akta SPRM 2009. Pertuduhan itu berkaitan dakwaan bahawa seorang pengarah syarikat memberikan suapan RM321,350 bagi mendapatkan subkontrak penyewaan kapal untuk kerja cari gali minyak. Kes ini menunjukkan bahawa organisasi juga boleh berdepan pertuduhan atas tindakan individu yang bersekutu dengannya.
Renungan: Mengapakah organisasi perlu memastikan pekerja dan pengarah memahami polisi antirasuah?
17. Kontrak Hotel Rotana
Sweett Group ialah penyedia perkhidmatan profesional dalam sektor pembinaan di United Kingdom. Siasatan mendapati anak syarikatnya di Timur Tengah membuat bayaran rasuah kepada pegawai kanan sebuah syarikat insurans bagi memenangi kontrak perundingan untuk pembinaan Hotel Rotana di Abu Dhabi. Pada tahun 2015, Sweett mengaku bersalah kerana gagal mencegah rasuah. Syarikat itu didenda £2.25 juta dan diarahkan membayar kos siasatan.
Renungan: Apakah tanggungjawab pihak pengurusan untuk mencegah rasuah dalam operasi syarikat, termasuk di luar negara?
18. Syarikat kecil, kesan besar
Skansen Interiors ialah syarikat kecil dengan kira-kira 30 pekerja. Bekas pengarah urusannya merasuah seorang bekas pengurus projek untuk mendapatkan kontrak membaik pulih dua pejabat di London, bernilai kira-kira £6 juta. Pada tahun 2018, mahkamah mensabitkan Skansen kerana gagal melaksanakan usaha mencukupi untuk mencegah rasuah. Walaupun syarikat itu tidak dikenakan penalti kewangan, kesalahan tersebut tetap membawa kesan undang-undang dan reputasi.
Renungan: Adakah saiz kecil sesebuah organisasi bermakna ia tidak memerlukan kawalan antirasuah?
19. Pengurusan baharu membuat laporan
Dalam kes Skansen, pengurusan baharu syarikat sendiri melaporkan perbuatan rasuah kepada pihak berkuasa dan memberikan kerjasama sepanjang siasatan. Tindakan itu menunjukkan bahawa organisasi boleh mengambil langkah bertanggungjawab apabila salah laku dikenal pasti, walaupun kesalahan tersebut melibatkan individu dalam organisasi.
Renungan: Mengapakah penting untuk menyediakan saluran pelaporan yang selamat dan boleh dipercayai?
20. Mencegah sebelum berlaku
Seksyen 17A membolehkan organisasi komersial dipertanggungjawabkan atas rasuah yang dilakukan oleh individu bersekutu untuk mendapatkan atau mengekalkan perniagaan. Garis panduan Tatacara Mencukupi memperkenalkan prinsip T.R.U.S.T.: komitmen pihak atasan, penilaian risiko, langkah kawalan, pemantauan dan penguatkuasaan yang sistematik, serta latihan dan komunikasi. Prinsip ini membantu organisasi membina budaya kerja yang menolak rasuah.
Renungan: Antara lima unsur T.R.U.S.T., yang manakah paling perlu diberi perhatian dalam organisasi anda? Mengapa?
17 November 2026
Felted miniature
Acrylic painting
30 Reflection Questions for DBA Students
A. Reflecting on Your Learning
What are the three most important things you have learnt from this course, and why are they important to you?
Which topic changed the way you think about accounting or financial information? How did your understanding change?
Before taking this course, what did you find most challenging about accounting and finance? How confident are you about it now?
How has your understanding of the purpose of financial reporting developed throughout the course?
Why is it important for financial statements to be prepared according to recognised accounting standards and regulations?
How would you explain the difference between internal and external users of financial information to someone without an accounting background?
What is the difference between profit and cash flow, and why can a profitable organisation still face financial difficulties?
How has learning about the accounting equation helped you understand the relationship between an organisation’s resources and its sources of financing?
What did you learn about accrual accounting, and how does it affect the way an organisation’s performance is reported?
Which topic would you like to explore further, and what questions do you still have about it?
B. Applying Your Learning in Your Current Career
How can you use financial information to make a better decision in your current role? Give a specific example.
What financial information would you examine before recommending a new project, investment or business initiative?
How could you use financial ratios to identify strengths or potential problems in your organisation?
If your organisation reported increasing sales but declining profits, what questions would you ask management?
How can knowledge of cash flow help you assess whether your organisation can meet its short-term obligations?
How might depreciation affect the reported performance and asset values of an organisation you are familiar with?
If your organisation belongs to a group of companies, how could consolidated financial statements help you understand the group’s overall position?
How could information about operating segments help you evaluate which parts of a business are performing well or require attention?
What financial risks might arise when an organisation conducts business in foreign currencies or operates in other countries?
How could financial planning and forecasting help you anticipate problems or opportunities in your workplace?
C. Developing as a Professional and Future DBA Graduate
How can you use financial information to communicate more effectively with senior management, colleagues or other stakeholders?
What would you do if financial reports appeared positive, but other evidence suggested that the organisation was experiencing problems?
How can an understanding of agency theory help you recognise conflicts of interest between owners, managers and other stakeholders?
What role should corporate governance play in ensuring that financial decisions are responsible, transparent and ethical?
How would you balance the need to achieve short-term financial targets with the organisation’s long-term sustainability?
How can financial statement analysis help you evaluate an organisation’s performance beyond simply looking at its reported profit?
What factors, other than financial figures, should be considered when assessing the value and long-term potential of a business?
How could you use what you have learnt in this course to identify a practical problem for your DBA research?
How might you combine financial evidence with your professional experience to develop a solution to that problem?
As a future DBA graduate, how do you intend to apply the knowledge from this course to create a positive impact on your organisation, profession or society?
16 November 2026
Auditors typically organise their working papers into two main types of audit files
| Type of audit file | Purpose | Examples of documents |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent audit file | Contains information that remains relevant across several audit years. The auditor updates it when circumstances change. | Company constitution, organisational chart, descriptions of the accounting system and internal controls, long-term loan agreements and lease agreements. |
| Current audit file | Contains documents relating to the audit of a specific financial year. It records the work performed, evidence obtained and conclusions reached. | Audit plan and programme for the year, year-end trial balance, bank confirmation letters, inventory count working papers, schedule of proposed audit adjustments, signed financial statements and the auditor’s report. |
Example: For a five-year bank loan, the loan agreement goes in the permanent file because its terms apply over several years. The bank confirmation of the year-end loan balance goes in the current file because it provides evidence for that particular year.
15 November 2026
Characteristics that make audit evidence persuasive
Audit evidence is persuasive when it is both sufficient and appropriate:
Persuasive means convincing enough to support a conclusion, even though it does not prove something with absolute certainty. In auditing, persuasive evidence gives the auditor a reasonable basis for their opinion.
- Sufficient: There is enough evidence. Higher assessed risk usually calls for more evidence.
- Relevant: The evidence directly supports the assertion being tested.
- Reliable: Evidence is generally stronger when it comes from an independent external source, is obtained directly by the auditor, or is supported by effective controls over its preparation.
- Consistent and corroborated: Evidence that agrees with other information from different sources strengthens the auditor’s conclusion. Conflicting evidence needs investigation.
No single characteristic guarantees that evidence is persuasive; the auditor considers the evidence as a whole. Audit evidence supports the auditor’s opinion but is usually persuasive rather than conclusive.
Physical examination and external confirmations
Physical examination and external confirmations can be expensive because they often require direct work beyond reviewing the client’s records.
- Physical examination: Auditors may need to travel to warehouses or other locations, attend an inventory count, inspect many items, and spend significant staff time. Specialist help or coordination across several sites may add cost.
- Confirmations: Auditors must prepare and send requests to banks, customers or suppliers, track replies, follow up on non-responses, and investigate differences. This can take time and may involve postage or secure confirmation platforms.
The actual cost depends on the audit. For example, examining one nearby asset may be inexpensive, while confirming many balances with overseas customers may be costly.
Persuasive rather than conclusive
* Persuasive means convincing and capable of influencing a conclusion or decision.
Audit evidence is persuasive rather than conclusive because an audit provides reasonable assurance, not absolute certainty. This is due to:
- Sampling: Auditors usually test selected items rather than every transaction.
- Use of judgement: Auditors must judge which procedures to perform and how to interpret the results.
- Estimates and uncertainty: Some figures, such as impairment or provisions, depend on assumptions about uncertain future events.
- Limits of internal controls: Controls may be overridden or bypassed through collusion.
- Possibility of concealed fraud: Fraud may involve falsified documents or carefully organised schemes that are difficult to detect.
- Limits on available information: Management or others may unintentionally or intentionally fail to provide complete information.
Therefore, auditors gather sufficient, appropriate evidence from different sources to support their opinion, but that evidence cannot prove every matter with absolute certainty.
Complex transactions and estimated balances can increase inherent risk
Complex transactions and estimated balances can increase inherent risk because they are more susceptible to material misstatement before considering the client’s internal controls.
- Complex transactions may involve complicated contract terms, several parties, multiple accounting rules or unusual timing. This makes errors in recognition, measurement, classification or disclosure more likely. For example, revenue from a long-term construction contract may depend on estimates of costs and progress.
- Estimated balances cannot always be measured directly and rely on data, models, assumptions and management judgement about uncertain future events. This creates estimation uncertainty and subjectivity, as well as opportunities for unintentional or intentional management bias. Examples include expected credit losses, impairment and provisions for litigation.
The more complex or uncertain the transaction or estimate, the greater the likelihood or possible size of a misstatement and therefore the higher the auditor may assess inherent risk. The auditor may respond with more focused procedures, such as testing assumptions and data or involving an expert.
Differences between audit risk and auditor’s business risk
| Audit risk | Auditor’s business risk |
|---|---|
| The risk that the auditor expresses an inappropriate opinion when the financial statements are materially misstated. | The risk of loss or harm to the auditor or audit firm arising from the engagement, such as litigation, reputational damage or loss of fees. |
| Relates to the accuracy of the audit opinion. | Relates to the auditor’s practice and business interests. |
| Managed by assessing misstatement risks and designing audit procedures to reduce audit risk to an acceptably low level. | Managed through client acceptance decisions, engagement quality management, adequate documentation and professional risk management. |
Example: If an auditor fails to detect a material misstatement and issues an inappropriate opinion, that is audit risk. If the client later sues the audit firm or the firm suffers reputational damage, that is auditor’s business risk.
The two may be connected, but they are not the same. ISA 200 specifically distinguishes audit risk from business risks such as litigation and adverse publicity.
Factors to consider when assessing materiality
Auditors use professional judgement and consider both quantitative and qualitative factors:
- Size of the misstatement: Its amount, relative to the financial statements, and whether it combines with other errors.
- Suitable benchmark: Such as profit before tax, revenue, total assets or equity. The benchmark depends on what users are likely to focus on and how stable the figure is.
- Nature of the item or error: A smaller amount may still be material if it involves fraud, a related party, legal or regulatory non-compliance, or affects a key disclosure.
- Effect on users’ decisions: For example, whether correcting an error changes a reported profit into a loss or causes a loan covenant to be breached.
- Entity circumstances: Its industry, size, stage of development, ownership structure, financing and current economic conditions.
- Importance of disclosures: Some information may matter to users because of its nature, even if it has no large monetary amount.
There is no single percentage that determines materiality in every audit; the auditor selects an appropriate benchmark and level based on the circumstances.
Why an engagement letter is important to the auditor
An engagement letter:
- Confirms the auditor’s appointment and records the agreed terms of the audit.
- Clarifies the audit’s objective and scope, helping prevent misunderstandings about what the auditor will do.
- Sets out each party’s responsibilities—the auditor’s and management’s.
- Identifies the financial reporting framework used to prepare the statements.
- Explains the expected auditor’s report and notes that its form may change depending on the audit findings.
- Confirms management’s duty to provide access to records, information and relevant staff.
- Provides a written reference if disagreements arise about the scope or conduct of the audit.
ISA 210 requires the agreed audit terms to be recorded in an engagement letter or another suitable written agreement.
Risks if preliminary procedures are inadequate
If auditors do not perform proper acceptance procedures, they may:
- Accept a client with poor integrity, increasing the risk of fraud, misleading information or management interference.
- Breach independence or ethical requirements because conflicts of interest or other threats were not identified and addressed.
- Accept work they cannot perform properly, due to insufficient expertise, staff, time or other resources.
- Begin the audit without agreed terms or preconditions, leading to disputes about management’s responsibilities, access to records or the scope of the audit.
- Overlook issues raised by the previous auditor or fail to consider why the client changed auditors.
- Misunderstand the applicable reporting framework or the client’s reporting responsibilities.
- Face financial, legal and reputational consequences if the audit is poorly performed or the auditor becomes associated with an unreliable client.
These failures may also lead to an inappropriate audit opinion. ISA 220 requires appropriate acceptance procedures; ISA 210 requires agreement on the audit preconditions and terms.
Key preliminary procedures before accepting an audit engagement
- Assess the client’s integrity — consider the reputation of management, owners and those charged with governance, and why the client is changing auditors.
- Check independence and ethical requirements — identify conflicts of interest or other threats and determine whether they can be resolved appropriately.
- Assess the firm’s capability and resources — confirm the team has the necessary expertise, time and resources, including access to specialists if needed.
- Consider relevant background information — review available information about the client, the nature of the engagement and any significant issues from a previous audit.
- Communicate with the predecessor auditor, where applicable, subject to relevant ethical requirements and the client’s permission.
- Confirm the audit preconditions — ensure the financial reporting framework is acceptable and management acknowledges its responsibilities for preparing the financial statements, internal control and providing access to information and staff.
- Agree and document the engagement terms — set out the scope, responsibilities, reporting framework and expected form of the auditor’s report, usually in an engagement letter.
If the auditor cannot meet ethical requirements, lacks appropriate resources, or the audit preconditions are absent, the firm should not accept the engagement. ISA 220 covers acceptance and resources; ISA 210 covers preconditions and terms; ISA 300 addresses predecessor communication for an initial audit.
International Standards on Auditing (ISA) for preliminary audit procedures
Relevant ISAs for preliminary audit procedures
- ISA 220 (Revised) — Quality Management for an Audit of Financial Statements: covers acceptance and continuance of client relationships and audit engagements, including whether the firm can meet ethical requirements and has appropriate resources. mia.org.my
- ISA 210 — Agreeing the Terms of Audit Engagements: requires the auditor to establish that the audit preconditions are present and agree the engagement terms with management. mia.org.my
- ISA 300 — Planning an Audit of Financial Statements: for an initial audit, requires the auditor to complete acceptance procedures under ISA 220 and communicate with the predecessor auditor, where applicable. mia.org.my
- ISA 315 (Revised 2019) — Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement: guides the auditor in understanding the client, its industry and internal controls, then identifying and assessing risks. It informs audit planning, but is not specifically an engagement-acceptance standard. mia.org.my
In summary: ISA 220 and ISA 210 are central to acceptance and agreeing terms; ISA 300 addresses initial audit procedures; ISA 315 guides the related understanding and risk assessment.
Sources of information available
Auditors obtain an understanding of the client’s business from internal and external sources, using more than one source to check that the information is consistent. ISA 315 requires auditors to understand the entity, its industry, regulatory environment, business model and financial performance. mia.org.my
| Source | Examples of information |
|---|---|
| Management and employees | Discussions with directors, finance staff, sales staff, internal auditors and those responsible for governance. |
| Internal documents and records | Business plans, budgets, management accounts, financial statements, minutes of meetings, organisation charts, policies, procedures and internal control documents. |
| Contracts and legal documents | Major customer and supplier contracts, loan agreements, leases, licences and legal correspondence. |
| Previous audit information | Prior-year financial statements, audit reports, working papers and previously identified control weaknesses, where relevant and available. |
| External sources | Industry publications, regulator and government information, economic data, trade journals, competitor information and relevant legal or tax guidance. |
| Direct observation and inspection | Visits to offices, factories, warehouses or retail locations; observing operations and inspecting assets or records. |
| Other professionals and business contacts | Information from lawyers, valuers, bankers or other experts, and—where appropriate—from customers or suppliers. |
The auditor evaluates whether each source is relevant and reliable; information from one source may need to be corroborated with another.
Key elements of a letter of weakness
A letter of weakness, often called a management letter, communicates internal control deficiencies identified during the audit and suggests ways to address them.
- Heading and recipient — date, client name, reporting period and the appropriate management or governance recipients.
- Purpose and scope — explain that the audit aimed to form an opinion on the financial statements, and was not designed to express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control.
- Summary of findings — briefly identify the main weaknesses and their significance.
- Details of each weakness, including:
- Condition: what the auditor found.
- Criteria: what should have happened or what control should exist.
- Cause: why the weakness may have occurred, if known.
- Potential effect or risk: how it could affect operations or the financial statements.
- Recommendation: practical action to address the weakness.
- Management’s response and action plan — proposed corrective action, responsible person and target date.
- Limitations and conclusion — clarify that the matters reported are those identified during the audit and considered important; further weaknesses may exist.
ISA 265 requires written communication of significant deficiencies to those charged with governance, including a description of the deficiencies, their potential effects and enough context to understand the communication. Recommendations and management’s responses may also be included.
Factors affecting the auditor’s judgement on the sufficiency of audit evidence
Sufficiency means the quantity of evidence obtained. The auditor considers:
- Risk of material misstatement: Higher risk generally requires more evidence.
- Materiality: A lower materiality level may require more testing to detect smaller errors.
- Reliability and relevance of evidence: Strong, relevant evidence may reduce how much additional evidence is needed.
- Results of testing: Errors, exceptions or conflicting evidence may require further procedures.
- Size and characteristics of the population: A larger or more varied population may require a larger sample.
- Evidence from other sources: Consistent, independent evidence can strengthen the overall conclusion.
More evidence cannot make up for evidence that is unreliable or irrelevant.
How analytical procedures help auditors set materiality and plan substantive procedures
Analytical procedures compare financial information with prior periods, budgets, expectations or industry data, and examine relationships between financial and non-financial information. They help the auditor understand the business and identify unusual trends or relationships that may indicate a risk of misstatement. mia.org.my
1. Helping assess materiality
Analytical procedures help the auditor understand which financial measures are most relevant to users and how stable they are. For example, comparisons of profit, revenue and total assets over several years may show that profit is unusually volatile. The auditor may then judge that profit is not a suitable benchmark for setting overall materiality and consider another benchmark, such as revenue or assets.
Analytical results inform the auditor’s professional judgement; they do not calculate materiality on their own.
2. Helping plan substantive procedures
Analytical procedures can highlight unexpected changes or relationships and help the auditor decide:
- Which accounts or assertions need more testing.
- What type of substantive procedures to use, such as analytical procedures or tests of details.
- How extensive the testing should be, based on the assessed risk.
Example: If the gross profit margin falls sharply, the auditor may investigate whether revenue is incomplete, expenses are overstated, or inventory is incorrectly valued. The auditor could test sales and purchase records, check year-end cut-off, and examine inventory valuation.
At the planning stage, analytical procedures help assess risk. Later, substantive analytical procedures may also be used to obtain audit evidence, provided the auditor can form a sufficiently precise expectation and investigate significant differences.
Relationship between detection risk and materiality
Detection risk and materiality generally have an inverse relationship in audit planning:
- Lower materiality level: Smaller errors may affect users’ decisions. The auditor should aim for lower detection risk by performing more extensive or persuasive procedures, such as increasing sample sizes or obtaining stronger evidence.
- Higher materiality level: Smaller errors are less likely to be considered material. The auditor may be able to accept higher detection risk and perform less extensive testing, provided the assessed risks and other audit requirements allow it.
Example: If the auditor sets a lower materiality level for an account, they need to test more items or obtain stronger evidence to reduce the chance of missing an error that could now be material.
The relationship is not automatic: the auditor also considers the risk of material misstatement. Overall, audit procedures must reduce audit risk to an acceptably low level.
Importance of developing an overall audit strategy
An overall audit strategy sets the audit’s broad direction. It helps the auditor:
- Define the audit’s scope—which entities, locations, reporting areas and requirements are covered.
- Set the timing of key work, such as interim testing and year-end procedures.
- Focus the team on significant areas and assessed risks, so audit effort is directed where material misstatements are more likely.
- Determine the resources needed, including staff with suitable skills and any experts.
- Plan direction, supervision and review of the engagement team’s work.
- Coordinate the audit, including communications with management and those charged with governance.
The strategy provides the framework for the detailed audit plan, which specifies the nature, timing and extent of audit procedures. It should be updated if circumstances or audit evidence change.
Audit tests performed by the auditor to examine the true and fair view of financial statement prepared by the company.
Auditors perform audit tests to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about whether the financial statements are fairly presented. These tests are commonly grouped into four categories:
| Category | Purpose | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Tests of controls | Check whether the company’s controls operate effectively to prevent or detect and correct misstatements. | Check whether sales transactions were properly approved. |
| 2. Substantive tests of transactions | Check whether individual transactions are recorded accurately and in the correct period and accounts. | Trace recorded sales to customer orders and delivery notes. |
| 3. Analytical procedures | Assess whether financial information is reasonable by examining relationships, trends or ratios. | Compare gross profit margins across periods and investigate unusual changes. |
| 4. Tests of details of balances | Verify the amounts and disclosures in year-end account balances. | Confirm accounts receivable with customers or inspect inventory. |
Tests of transactions, analytical procedures and tests of balance details are substantive procedures. In some audit standards, the last three are grouped under substantive procedures, which comprise tests of details and substantive analytical procedures.
Sufficiency of audit evidence
Sufficiency refers to the quantity of audit evidence the auditor obtains. The auditor gathers enough relevant evidence to support conclusions about the financial statements and form an audit opinion with reasonable assurance.
The amount of evidence required depends on several factors:
- Assessed risk: Higher risk of material misstatement generally means the auditor needs more evidence or more extensive testing.
- Reliability of the evidence: Strong, reliable evidence may allow the auditor to obtain a conclusion from a smaller quantity of evidence. Less reliable evidence may require additional corroboration.
- Results of testing: If a sample reveals errors or exceptions, the auditor may need to increase the sample, perform further procedures or reassess the risk.
- Importance of the account or assertion: Significant or sensitive areas may require more audit work.
For example, if the auditor assesses a high risk that accounts receivable is overstated, they may confirm more customer balances and investigate exceptions.
Remember: Sufficiency is about how much evidence; appropriateness is about its quality - including relevance and reliability. More evidence is not automatically better if it is unreliable.
Factors affect the auditor’s assessment of risk of material misstatement
Audit risk is affected by the likelihood that the financial statements contain a material misstatement and the chance that the auditor’s procedures will not detect it. The factors below mainly affect the auditor’s assessment of risk of material misstatement.
i. Integrity of management
- High integrity: Management demonstrates honesty, ethical behaviour and a willingness to provide complete information. This may indicate a stronger control environment and a lower assessed risk of fraud or management bias.
- Low integrity: Dishonesty, misleading explanations, prior fraud or reluctance to provide information raises the risk of fraudulent reporting, management bias and override of controls. The auditor should assess risk as higher, maintain professional scepticism and obtain stronger evidence.
Management’s apparent integrity does not remove the need for audit procedures; auditors should not rely on trust alone. mia.org.my
ii. Approval and authorisation of transactions
- Effective approvals: Clear authority limits, independent approval and evidence of review can prevent or detect unauthorised transactions. If the controls are properly designed and operating effectively, the auditor may assess control risk as lower.
- Weak or missing approvals: Transactions may be unauthorised, fraudulent or incorrectly recorded. The auditor should assess control risk as higher and consider increasing substantive testing.
In addition to management integrity and approval and authorisation of transactions, auditors may consider these factors when assessing audit risk:
| Factor | May indicate higher risk | May indicate lower risk |
|---|---|---|
| iii. Segregation of duties | One person controls several stages of a transaction, increasing the opportunity for error or fraud. | Duties are divided so that one person’s work is checked by another. |
| iv. Competence of accounting staff | Staff lack experience or training, increasing the chance of accounting errors. | Staff are qualified, experienced and receive appropriate supervision. |
| v. Effectiveness of internal controls | Controls are missing, poorly designed or not consistently followed. | Controls are suitably designed and operate effectively. |
| vi. Complexity of transactions and estimates | Complex transactions or estimates require significant judgement, creating greater scope for error or management bias. | Transactions and estimates are straightforward and supported by reliable information. |
| vii. Financial pressure on the entity | Financial distress, pressure to meet targets or loan covenant requirements may increase incentives to manipulate results. | The entity is financially stable and faces less pressure to misstate results. |
| viii. Previous audit findings | Prior-period errors, control deficiencies or frequent adjustments suggest problems may continue. | Few recurring errors and timely correction of past audit findings may indicate lower risk. |
| ix. Accounting and IT systems | Recent system changes, weak access controls or unreliable data increase the risk of errors or unauthorised changes. | Systems are stable, access is restricted and data is properly checked. |
| x. Unusual or related-party transactions | Unusual, non-routine or related-party transactions may be complex, improperly recorded or insufficiently disclosed. | Transactions are routine, well documented and properly reviewed. |
| xi. Industry and regulatory environment | Rapid changes, strict regulation or volatile industry conditions can increase reporting uncertainty and compliance risk. | A stable environment with clear requirements may reduce some risks. |
These factors help assess the risk of material misstatement and determine the nature, timing and extent of audit procedures. They are considered together; one favourable factor does not by itself establish that audit risk is low.
Ways to reduce detection risk
Detection risk is the risk that the auditor’s procedures fail to detect a material misstatement. The auditor can reduce it by:
- Designing procedures to address the assessed risks and relevant financial statement assertions.
- Increasing the extent of testing, such as testing a larger sample or examining more transactions.
- Obtaining more reliable evidence, such as direct confirmations from banks or customers.
- Performing procedures closer to year-end when balances or transactions may change significantly.
- Using a mix of audit procedures, such as inspection, confirmation, recalculation and analytical procedures.
- Assigning experienced staff to complex or high-risk areas, with proper supervision and review.
- Using unpredictable procedures where fraud risk is a concern, such as selecting unexpected items for testing.
The higher the assessed risk of material misstatement, the more persuasive the evidence the auditor should obtain. These actions reduce detection risk, but cannot eliminate it completely.
Distinguish between control risk and detection risk
| Control risk | Detection risk |
|---|---|
| The risk that the client’s internal controls fail to prevent, detect or correct a material misstatement on time. | The risk that the auditor’s procedures fail to detect a material misstatement that exists. |
| Relates to the client’s internal control system. | Relates to the auditor’s audit procedures. |
| The auditor assesses it by understanding and, where relevant, testing the client’s controls. | The auditor manages it by designing appropriate procedures and gathering sufficient evidence. |
Example: If purchase approvals are weak, an unauthorised payment may not be stopped—this is control risk. If the auditor’s testing then fails to find that payment, this is detection risk.
Both contribute to audit risk: audit risk = risk of material misstatement × detection risk.
Assertion tested by an audit procedure
To identify the assertion tested by an audit procedure, focus on what the procedure is trying to prove. The same procedure can support different assertions depending on its purpose.
| If the procedure checks whether… | Assertion | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded items actually exist | Existence | Attend the inventory count and inspect selected items on the inventory listing. |
| The entity owns or is responsible for the item | Rights and obligations | Inspect title documents for property recorded as an asset. |
| All items that should be recorded are included | Completeness | Select items from the warehouse floor and trace them to the inventory listing. |
| The amount is correct and properly valued | Accuracy, valuation and allocation | Check inventory cost calculations and whether obsolete items are written down. |
| The balance is recorded in the correct category | Classification | Check that short-term borrowings are not recorded as long-term liabilities. |
| The balance is properly grouped and disclosed | Presentation | Check that inventory is clearly presented and required disclosures are included. |
Useful direction rule: Checking from the accounting records to supporting evidence often tests existence. Checking from source evidence to the accounting records often tests completeness. The assertion ultimately depends on the objective of the procedure.
Assertions about account balances
Assertions are claims management makes about account balances in the financial statements. The auditor uses them to identify what could be misstated and plan audit procedures. Under ISA 315, the main assertions for account balances at period end are: mia.org.my
| Assertion | Meaning | Example: inventory |
|---|---|---|
| Existence | The recorded assets, liabilities and equity balances exist. | Inventory recorded in the accounts is physically present. |
| Rights and obligations | The entity owns or controls the recorded assets, and recorded liabilities are its obligations. | Goods held on consignment for another business are not recorded as the entity’s inventory. |
| Completeness | All balances that should be recorded have been included. | Inventory held at another location is included in the records. |
| Accuracy, valuation and allocation | Balances are recorded at appropriate amounts, and related adjustments are properly recorded. | Damaged or obsolete inventory is valued appropriately. |
| Classification | Balances are recorded in the correct accounts or categories. | Inventory is not incorrectly recorded as equipment. |
| Presentation | Balances are appropriately grouped, described and disclosed in the financial statements. | Inventory is separately and clearly presented, with required disclosures. |
Existence checks whether recorded items are real; completeness checks whether all items that should be recorded are included. ISA 315 groups some assertions differently across transactions, balances and disclosures, so use the account-balance wording when answering a question specifically about balances.
Risk assessment
- Risk assessment is an essential part of audit planning.
- The auditor needs to understand the entity and identify where material misstatements may occur before deciding which audit procedures to perform.
- ISA 315 requires auditors to identify and assess risks of material misstatement; ISA 300 requires the audit plan to reflect the planned risk assessment and further procedures. mia.org.my
- Risk assessment does not waste time.
- It helps the auditor focus effort on high-risk areas, choose appropriate procedures, and allocate staff and time effectively.
- If auditors skip this step and begin detailed testing immediately, they may test low-risk areas unnecessarily while overlooking significant risks, including fraud.
- This can make the audit less effective and may lead to insufficient evidence or an inappropriate opinion.
- Risk assessment is also ongoing.
- Substantive testing may uncover new information, but if that happens, the auditor should update the risk assessment and modify the audit plan as needed. mia.org.my
Conclusion: Auditors should not bypass or minimise risk assessment. A well-planned risk assessment helps make detailed audit procedures more focused, efficient and responsive to the risks.
Important planning procedures for a new audit client
For a new client, the auditor should complete preliminary acceptance work and then plan the audit based on the client’s circumstances and risks.
Assess whether to accept the engagement. Consider the client’s integrity, the firm’s independence, relevant expertise and whether enough suitable resources are available.
Agree the terms of the engagement. Confirm the audit’s scope, applicable financial reporting framework, management’s responsibilities and the form of the auditor’s report.
Communicate with the predecessor auditor, if another firm audited the previous period, in line with ethical requirements. Where permitted, arrange to review relevant working papers.
Understand the client and its environment. Learn about its business, industry, operations, ownership, accounting policies, legal and regulatory requirements, and financial reporting process.
Understand internal controls and assess risks. Identify areas where material misstatement due to error or fraud may occur, including significant account balances, transactions and disclosures.
Set materiality to help plan audit procedures and evaluate identified misstatements.
Plan the audit strategy and procedures. Decide the audit scope, timing and approach, including which controls to test and what substantive procedures to perform.
Assign appropriate staff and supervision. Consider the skills and experience needed for higher-risk areas, and plan how the team’s work will be directed and reviewed.
Consider opening balances. In an initial audit engagement, obtain evidence that opening balances do not materially affect the current period’s financial statements, and that accounting policies have been applied consistently or changes have been properly accounted for. mia.org.my
The auditor should document the overall strategy and audit plan, then update them if new information changes the assessed risks or planned work.
Consequences of inadequate audit planning
Inadequate audit planning can lead to:
- Failure to identify or detect material misstatements, including fraud.
- Insufficient or inappropriate audit evidence, making it difficult to support the auditor’s opinion.
- Audit procedures that do not address key risks, resulting in important accounts or assertions being inadequately tested.
- Inefficient use of time and resources, which can increase audit costs or delay completion.
- Poor coordination and supervision, leading to duplicated work, gaps or errors in the team’s work.
- An inappropriate audit opinion if significant issues are missed or evidence is inadequate.
- Damage to the auditor’s reputation and possible professional or legal consequences.
Audit planning must be updated when new information changes the auditor’s understanding of risks or the work required.
Common weaknesses in audit planning
- Insufficient understanding of the client - not learning enough about its business, industry, operations or reporting requirements.
- Poor risk assessment - failing to identify areas where material misstatement or fraud is more likely.
- Inappropriate materiality levels - setting materiality without considering the needs of financial statement users.
- Audit procedures that do not address the risks - for example, using procedures that do not properly test the relevant account or assertion.
- Poor timing and resource allocation - scheduling work too late or not assigning enough time, staff or expertise to high-risk areas.
- Inadequate direction, supervision and review - team members may misunderstand their tasks, or errors in their work may go unnoticed.
- Failure to update the plan - continuing with the original plan even when new information or audit evidence changes the risk assessment.
- Insufficient documentation - not recording the audit strategy, plan or reasons for significant changes.
What is the auditor trying to test?
ISA 330 distinguishes tests of controls from substantive procedures; substantive procedures include tests of details and substantive analytical procedures. mia.org.my
| Procedure | What the auditor tests | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Test of control | Whether a control operated effectively. | Inspecting sales invoices for evidence of required approval. |
| Substantive test of transactions | Whether individual transactions were recorded correctly. | Checking a sample of recorded sales to customer orders and delivery notes. |
| Test of details of balances | Whether an ending account balance is correct. | Sending confirmations to customers to verify accounts receivable at year-end. |
| Analytical procedure | Whether relationships or trends in financial and non-financial data are reasonable. | Comparing monthly gross profit margins and investigating an unexpected change. |
Quick guide
- Checks approval, authorisation or another control? → Test of control
- Checks individual transactions? → Substantive test of transactions
- Checks the year-end balance? → Test of details of balances
- Compares figures, ratios or trends? → Analytical procedure
The classification depends on the purpose of the audit step. For example, inspecting an invoice for an approval signature tests a control; inspecting it to verify the amount recorded in the sales account tests a transaction. Analytical procedures involve evaluating plausible relationships and investigating significant differences.
Factors that affect the reliability of audit evidence
Under ISA 500, reliability depends on the evidence’s source, nature and the circumstances in which it is obtained. mia.org.my
- Source: Evidence from an independent external party is generally more reliable than evidence produced internally.
- Internal controls: Internally generated records are more reliable when the controls over their preparation and maintenance are effective.
- How the auditor obtains it: Evidence obtained directly by the auditor—such as observing a control—is generally more reliable than evidence obtained indirectly through enquiry.
- Form of evidence: Original documents are generally more reliable than copies or electronic versions, unless the controls over creating and maintaining those versions are reliable.
- Authenticity and competence: The auditor considers whether the evidence is genuine and whether its source is knowledgeable and impartial.
- Consistency: Evidence that agrees with information from other independent sources is generally more convincing. Conflicting evidence needs investigation.
- Timing and relevance: Evidence should relate to the period and assertion being audited.
Note: An external document is not automatically reliable, and inquiry alone usually does not provide sufficient evidence. Auditors consider the quality of evidence, not just how much they collect.
PODCIAR
PODCIAR is a mnemonic for common audit procedures used to obtain evidence:
| Procedure | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| P – Physical examination | Inspecting a tangible asset to check that it exists and assess its condition. | Inspecting inventory or equipment. |
| O – Observation | Watching a process or procedure being performed. | Observing the client’s year-end inventory count. |
| D – Documentation | Examining documents or records that support transactions or balances. | Checking supplier invoices or delivery orders. |
| C – Confirmation | Obtaining a direct response from an independent third party. | Asking a bank to confirm the company’s account balance. |
| I – Inquiry | Asking knowledgeable people for information, verbally or in writing. | Asking management about an unusual expense. |
| A – Analytical procedures | Evaluating financial information by comparing relationships and investigating unexpected differences. | Comparing this year’s gross profit margin with last year’s. |
| R – Recalculation and re-performance | Recalculation: checking mathematical accuracy. Re-performance: independently repeating a procedure or control. | Recalculating depreciation or re-performing a bank reconciliation. |
These procedures may be combined. Inquiry alone is usually not enough to support a conclusion; auditors generally corroborate responses with other evidence.
audit risk = risk of material misstatement × detection risk
Materiality and its relationship with risk of material misstatement
Materiality is the level at which an error or omission in the financial statements could reasonably influence users’ decisions. Auditors set materiality using professional judgement, considering both the amount and nature of a misstatement. They use it when planning the audit and evaluating identified errors. mia.org.my
Risk of material misstatement (RMM) is the risk that the financial statements are materially misstated before the audit. At the assertion level, it comprises inherent risk and control risk. mia.org.my
How they relate
- Materiality sets the benchmark; RMM assesses the chance of a misstatement reaching that benchmark.
- A misstatement may be material on its own or when combined with other misstatements.
- If the auditor sets a lower materiality level, smaller errors may affect users’ decisions, so the auditor may need more extensive procedures.
- If the auditor assesses RMM as high, the auditor responds by obtaining more persuasive evidence and adjusting the nature, timing and extent of audit procedures.
Example: If materiality is RM100,000, an error of RM5,000 may not be material by itself. But many similar errors could add up to a material amount. If the account also has weak controls, the auditor may assess a higher RMM and increase testing.
In summary: Materiality concerns the importance or size of a possible misstatement; RMM concerns its likelihood and potential magnitude. Materiality is not itself a component of RMM, but it helps the auditor assess and respond to that risk.
Ways an auditor can reduce the risk of failing to detect a material misstatement
- Apply professional scepticism — question unusual explanations and consider evidence that contradicts management’s claims.
- Assess risks carefully — understand the entity, its business and internal controls to identify where material errors or fraud could occur.
- Design audit procedures to match the risks — the higher the assessed risk, the more persuasive the evidence the auditor should obtain. mia.org.my
- Gather sufficient and appropriate evidence — use suitable procedures such as inspection, observation, confirmation, recalculation and analytical procedures.
- Test controls if relying on them — check that relevant controls are operating effectively; otherwise, increase substantive testing.
- Focus on areas requiring judgement — for example, accounting estimates, unusual transactions and journal entries, where management bias or fraud may occur.
- Use appropriate sampling and follow up exceptions — investigate errors found and consider whether they indicate wider problems.
- Review the audit evidence overall — reconsider the risk assessment if evidence conflicts or suggests another misstatement may exist.
An audit provides reasonable assurance, not a guarantee that every material misstatement will be detected. These steps help reduce detection risk.
Relationship between internal control and risk of material misstatement
Risk of material misstatement (RMM) is the risk that the financial statements contain a material error or fraud before the auditor’s work. At the assertion level, it consists of inherent risk and control risk. Control risk is the possibility that the entity’s internal controls fail to prevent, detect or correct a misstatement on time. mia.org.my
- Effective internal controls can lower control risk by reducing the chance that errors or fraud go undetected.
- Weak or missing controls increase control risk, which can increase the auditor’s assessed RMM.
- If controls are weak, RMM is higher, so the auditor may do more substantive testing. If the auditor plans to rely on controls, they must test whether those controls operated effectively.
Example: If one employee can create suppliers, approve purchases and arrange payments, a fictitious supplier payment may go undetected. Separating these duties helps reduce that risk. Internal controls reduce risk, but cannot eliminate it completely.
Types of misstatements
Misstatements can be described in two ways: by their cause and by how the auditor classifies them during the audit.
1. By cause
- Error: An unintentional mistake or omission in the financial statements.
- Fraud: An intentional act to deceive, such as deliberately misstating or omitting information. Fraud may involve:
- Fraudulent financial reporting — deliberately manipulating the financial statements.
- Misappropriation of assets — stealing or improperly using the organisation’s assets. www.iaasb.org
2. By audit classification (ISA 450)
- Factual: A definite error with no reasonable disagreement, such as omitting a supplier invoice.
- Judgemental: Management’s accounting judgement or policy is unreasonable or inappropriate, such as an unjustifiably low bad-debt allowance.
- Projected: The auditor estimates the likely error in the full population from errors found in a sample. mia.org.my
Key point: Fraud is not a fourth ISA 450 classification. It describes the intentional cause of a misstatement; a fraud-related misstatement may also be classified as factual, judgemental or projected.
Roles of those charged with governance in relation to fraud
Those charged with governance (TCWG)—usually the board of directors or audit committee—provide oversight. Management remains primarily responsible for preparing the financial statements and establishing controls to prevent and detect fraud.
TCWG should:
- Oversee management’s assessment of fraud risks and its plans to address them.
- Monitor the controls and processes management uses to prevent, detect and respond to fraud.
- Promote integrity and ethical conduct through the organisation’s culture and leadership.
- Challenge management’s explanations and seek further information when something appears unusual.
- Oversee the handling of fraud allegations, including ensuring that concerns are investigated and addressed appropriately.
- Communicate with the external auditor about known, suspected or alleged fraud, and consider the auditor’s concerns and findings.
In short, TCWG oversee and challenge; management is responsible for operating the controls and preparing the financial statements.
Actions auditors should take when they detect or suspect fraud
Maintain professional scepticism. Do not accept explanations at face value. Gather and assess reliable evidence, including evidence that may contradict management’s explanation.
Understand and investigate the matter. Make appropriate enquiries, establish what happened and who may be involved, and consider whether the issue points to a wider fraud risk or a weakness in internal controls.
Inform the appropriate people. Report the matter promptly to an appropriate level of management. If senior management may be involved, communicate directly with those charged with governance, such as the audit committee or board.
Reassess and adjust the audit. Reconsider the assessed risks, the reliability of information and management representations, and whether more or different audit procedures are needed.
Consider reporting obligations. Determine whether law, regulation or professional requirements require reporting to an external authority. The auditor should follow applicable confidentiality requirements and obtain legal advice where appropriate.
Assess the effect on the audit opinion. If the financial statements remain materially misstated and management does not correct them, consider a modified opinion. Consider whether the auditor can continue the engagement.
Document the work. Record the evidence, enquiries, communications, conclusions and decisions made.
The auditor’s role is to respond to fraud risks and assess their effect on the financial statements; deciding whether a crime has legally occurred is for the relevant authorities. IAASB
Standards note: Revised ISA 240 is effective for audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026
Management’s responsibilities in relation to financial statements
- Preparing and fairly presenting the financial statements in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework, such as MFRS.
- Maintaining appropriate internal controls so the statements are free from material misstatement caused by fraud or error.
- Keeping proper accounting records and providing the auditor with relevant information and access to staff.
- Making reasonable accounting estimates and judgements, and providing adequate disclosures.
- Assessing whether the going concern basis is appropriate and disclosing any significant uncertainties.
- Taking responsibility for the financial statements, including confirming this responsibility in writing when requested by the auditor.


















.jpeg)



